"You weren't supposed to choose me," he said. Behind them, Ira approached, stunned and speechless for what must have been the first time in his life. He helped lift Samuel, whose cheeks had blanched as well. Camille prodded Oscar's arms and stomach and face. It was truly him. The unbearable grief over losing him flipped inside out. Her joy ran so deep and strong she thought she might burst from it. "The night the went down, you rowed to me," she answered, her throat knotted as she thought of her father. She forced it down. "This time, I must have needed to row to you." Oscar kissed her, his lips still cold but filled with life. She leaned into him and hung on as though he might disappear. Ira let out a playful high-pitched whistle. Samuel coughed. Oscar and Camille reluctantly pulled apart and blushed. "Holy gallnipper," Ira said. Camille grinned, not minding in the least that he was using that annoying turn of phrase again. "I can't believe that little rock...I mean you were dead, mate. Dead as this bloke right here." Ira kicked McGreenery in the leg. Oscar nodded, rubbing his hand over the fading red mark, as if to feel for himself that the deadly wound was gone. "I was in the dory," he whispered. Ira cocked his head. "Say again?" Camille lifted her ear from his chest, where she'd wanted to listen to the smooth rhythm of his heart. She looked up at him before hearing its strong beat. "The dory?" Oscar nodded again, eyebrows creased. "I heard your voice. At the cave," he said to Camille. "This force kept pulling me backward, away from you, like I was being sucked into the ground." So this was how it had felt for him to die. She remembered the way he'd looked right through her and how it had chilled her to the marrow. Her own brush with death had been different, and somehow better, if death could even be measured in levels of bad or good. The image of her father had drawn her to safety, making her forget her yearning for air. He had been there for her, but she hadn't been able to do the same for him. All this time, all this trouble, and all she'd wanted was to bring him back, make him proud of the lengths to which she'd gone for him. In the end, she'd failed him miserably. "And then you were gone. Your voice faded, and I was in the dory, adrift in the Tasman, the dawn after the went down," Oscar continued. Samuel and Ira glanced at each other with marked expressions of doubt and confusion. "But I wasn't alone." He gently pulled Camille away from him and gripped her arms. "Your father was with me. He was sitting there, smiling. It all seemed so real. I could taste the salt air, and...and I remember touching the water, and it was cold. It wasn't like in a dream, when you can't do those things." Camille sucked in a deep breath, trying to inflate her crushing lungs. Oscar had seen him, too. She'd give anything to see her father again, to hear his voice, to feel at home by just being in his presence. At least, that's what she'd once believed. But Camille hadn't been willing to give up Oscar. Did that mean she loved her father less? Never. She could love her fatherless. So then why hadn't her heart chosen him? "Did he say anything?" she asked, anxious to know yet afraid to hear. "It's all jumbled," Oscar said, again shaking his head and rubbing his chest. "I remember him saying a few things. Bits and pieces." Camille looked to Ira and Samuel. Their parted mouths and bugged eyes hung on Oscar's every word. Oscar squinted at the ground and seemed to be working hard to piece together what her father had said on the other side. " " he said, questioning his own memory. "It doesn't make any sense, I'm sorry." She shook her head, eyes tearing up again. It had been real. He really had come to her in the black water of the underground pool. "No, don't be sorry," she said, tears spilling. "It does make sense. It makes sense to me."