"eight thousand Republicans crammed into Crosby's Opera House for a veritable coronation of Ulysses S. Grant. To play on wartime memories, General John "Black Jack" Logan was designated to place his name in nomination. His speech was followed by a well-staged extravaganza: hats and handkerchiefs fluttered, rounds of applause rippled across the house, and a pigeon, dyed red, white, and blue, flapped through the cavernous space. As a huge ovation for his son gathered strength, Jesse Grant stood before the speaker's platform in "mute astonishment," said a reporter.8 Then a curtain rose to reveal huge images drawn by Thomas Nast of the Goddess of Liberty, juxtaposed with Grant. To no one's surprise, Grant won by acclamation on the first ballot."